Dr. Kristin Francis, who works with families on coparenting, says sharing a holiday is not about which parent gets more time. It is about which parent protects the child from conflict, and she calls a calm, drama-free schedule the most loving gift parents can give.
Why do kids care so much if exes share a holiday?
Holidays carry memories. For children whose parents have split, the season can bring back the sadness of the breakup and the pressure of feeling torn between two homes. Many kids quietly hope for one day when everyone is in the same room. When exes pull it off, children get a sense that their family still holds together, even if it looks different now.
What does research say about exes and conflict?
The research centers on conflict rather than the calendar. Sociologist Nicholas Wolfinger says parental conflict explains many of the poor outcomes children of divorce face. Studies show that splitting up can benefit kids when conflict is high, and that children suffer when parents keep fighting after the breakup.
That means the setting matters less than the mood. A quiet dinner together beats two separate holidays filled with tension. Two peaceful holidays beat one shared meal that ends in a blowup.
When should exes skip spending holidays together?
Some signs say set two tables. If old hurts are still raw, if one parent has a new partner the other has not accepted, or if children might read a shared dinner as a sign their parents are getting back together, a joint holiday can backfire. Mediators at Linder Mediation in Arizona warn that the first few holidays after a split are often the hardest, and separate celebrations may protect everyone. Distance, money and work schedules can also make one gathering unrealistic.
What are other holiday options for exes with kids?
Parents who choose to celebrate separately still have choices that keep kids at the center.
- Two celebrations. Children enjoy the holiday twice, once at each home on different days.
- Alternating years. One parent hosts this year, and the other hosts next year.
- Assigned holidays. One parent always takes Thanksgiving and the other always takes Christmas.
- Shared day. Parents who live close split the day, morning at one house and evening at the other.
- Extended family gathering. Grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins fill the room, which takes the spotlight off the exes.
That last option comes naturally for a lot of families. In many Black households, the holiday already means a packed house at Grandma’s, kids running between rooms and plates going home with everybody. For some exes, that crowd and that love make sharing the day easier than sitting across from each other alone.
How can exes make a shared holiday work?
Agree on the plan early and tell the children what to expect. Family law attorney Shari Bornstein recommends deciding ahead of time whether gifts will come from both parents together or separately, and who covers which presents. If the kids spend the day apart from one parent, the Gottman Institute notes a quick phone call with that parent can ease their sadness.
Keep the visit short if it is the first try, leave old arguments at the door and focus on the kids. Children will not remember who sat where. They will remember whether their parents made the day feel safe.

